Niccol's 'Back To Starbucks' Plan Shows Some Signs Of Progress In Earnings Announcement But Results Are Still Mixed – CoffeeTalk

Starbucks reported mixed financial results for the fiscal fourth quarter, with total revenue increasing 5.5% year-over-year to $9.57 billion, exceeding consensus estimates of $9.35 billion. Adjusted earnings per share (EPS) came in at 52 cents, falling short of projections at 56 cents, and reflecting a 35% decline compared to the prior year. The company’s same-store sales saw a modest rise of 1% globally, surpassing a potential decline of 0.3% as predicted by FactSet. This metric, crucial in the restaurant industry, accounts for the effects of store openings and closures, and fluctuations in currency.

Although Starbucks’ stock was down slightly in after-hours trading, the company’s performance emerged positively against a challenging backdrop for the entire restaurant sector. Broader investor sentiment has been cautious, reflecting concerns over U.S. consumer health and spending in restaurants, as indicated by the significant drops in other chains like Chipotle and Brinker International.

CEO Brian Niccol’s turnaround efforts are noticeable, particularly in the U.S. market. Despite flat comparable store sales in the July-September quarter, positive trends emerged in September, suggesting customer satisfaction is improving, driven by transaction growth rather than price increases. Notably, the new staffing and operating model, Green Apron Service, was implemented successfully, with more than 80% of stores meeting the service goal of “4 minutes or less.”

Starbucks’ Chinese operations also showed promise, with same-store sales climbing 2% amid a competitive landscape, bolstered by a large 9% increase in transaction numbers, albeit countered by a 7% drop in average ticket size due to strategic pricing adjustments. This marked a significant recovery from past declines, as the company has now reported two consecutive quarters of positive same-store sales in China.

While the quarterly results were not exceptional, they were solid, aligning with Niccol’s long-term vision for the company. Despite challenges in profitability metrics, critics argue that Niccol’s investment in staffing and store upgrades could limit earnings potential. However, there is a belief that these investments will ultimately stimulate topline growth, with ongoing cost discipline expected to enhance earnings.

Starbucks is set to release more concrete guidance for 2026 and beyond during an upcoming investor day in January. CFO Cathy Smith expressed confidence in traversing the path towards sustainable earnings growth, emphasizing the priority of topline growth before seeing earnings improvements. In tandem with strategic measures, Starbucks closed 627 stores—mostly in North America—as part of its restructuring efforts, aimed at improving overall customer experience and enhancing operating margins despite a potential short-term revenue dip.

Read More @ CNBC